Nepomniachtchi v Ding, 2023 tiebreak: Ding becomes champion
The 2023 World Championship in Astana, between Ian Nepomniachtchi and Ding Liren, finished level at 7–7 after the classical games, and went to rapid tiebreaks on 30 April 2023. The first three were drawn. In the fourth, with Black and with both players short of time, Ding turned down a repetition and won, taking the match 9½–8½.
Find the move. Find the move Ding played at move 60.
Find the moveThe whole game
The opening was a Ruy Lopez, with Nepomniachtchi's unusual 13.Bb1. White won a pawn, gave it back, and from move 39 the game was level. Then both players were in severe time trouble, with under a minute on the clock for much of the endgame, and the evaluation swung back and forth.
What Stockfish makes of it
We had Stockfish check every move. It agrees with the commentators' main marks, and it shows how many times the result changed hands in the last 25 moves.
42...Qe2 and 46...Rg6: Ding plays on
Wikipedia calls 42...Qe2 a brilliancy, and Stockfish rates it the only move that kept the balance. Nepomniachtchi then offered a repetition with checks on e4 and d5. With 46...Rg6 Ding stepped out of it, putting his rook in a pin against his own king; Carlsen's comment was "Self-pinning for immortality". Stockfish rates 46...Rg6 as giving White a fifth of a pawn more than the repetition would have, but it isn't a mistake that loses anything: the position stays close to level.
47.Qf5 and 48.h4: the first swing
Wikipedia marks 47.Qf5 as dubious and 48.h4 as a mistake. Stockfish agrees: after 47.Qf5 c4 the game was still about level, but only one move held it, 48.Qf4, which Rafael Leitão called "totally not human". After 48.h4 Qd3 Black is nearly three pawns better.
Moves 53 to 63: back and forth
With less than a minute on either clock the game turned several more times. 53...Rd6 let most of Black's advantage go: 53...c2 would have kept it at over four pawns. By move 58 Stockfish rated the game level again. Then 59.Qc7, which Wikipedia also marks as an error, gave Black a winning position once more; 59.h5 would have held. 62.Kg2 made it worse, and Ding's 62...h5 was the only move that kept his advantage. After 63.Kf1 Stockfish rates Black about ten pawns better.
The finish
Ding's 63...Be5 let some of that go too, but White's 64.g4 and 65.h5 didn't help, and after 67.f4 Stockfish sees a forced mate. After 68...Bxf4, with under 30 seconds left, Nepomniachtchi resigned.
How we checked
- The moves are from Wikipedia's page on the 2023 match. We replayed every one with python-chess: all are legal.
- The engine: Stockfish 17.1 checked every move at depth 22, and the key moments again at depth 26. "A pawn better" is Stockfish's measure of the position, not a count of material.
- The history and the named opinions (the match score, the date, the move marks, Leitão and Carlsen's comments, the clock times) are from the Wikipedia article.
Try it. Real positions, set at your level, every answer checked against the board. No account needed to start.
Start trainingMore famous games
- The Immortal Game
- The Evergreen Game
- The Opera Game
- Zukertort v Blackburne, London 1883
- Lasker v Bauer, Amsterdam 1889
- Steinitz v von Bardeleben, Hastings 1895
- Rotlewi v Rubinstein, Łódź 1907
- Levitsky v Marshall, Breslau 1912
- Edward Lasker vs Thomas, 1912
- Lasker v Capablanca, St Petersburg 1914
- Capablanca v Marshall, New York 1918
- Adams vs Torre, 1920
- The Immortal Zugzwang Game
- Réti v Alekhine, Baden-Baden 1925
- Euwe vs Alekhine 1935, game 26
- Botvinnik v Capablanca, AVRO 1938
- The Game of the Century
- Polugaevsky v Nezhmetdinov, Sochi 1958
- Tal v Smyslov, Candidates 1959
- Spassky v Bronstein, 1960
- Tal v Botvinnik, 1960, game 1
- Robert Byrne v Fischer, 1963
- Petrosian v Spassky, 1966, game 10
- Spassky v Petrosian, 1969, game 19
- Larsen v Spassky, Belgrade 1970
- Fischer v Spassky, 1972, game 6
- Karpov v Spassky, 1974, game 9
- Liu Wenzhe v Donner, 1978
- Karpov v Kasparov, 1985, game 16
- Kasparov v Karpov, Seville 1987, game 24
- Shirov v Judit Polgár, Buenos Aires 1994
- Topalov v Shirov, Linares 1998
- Kasparov's Immortal
- Kasparov v Kramnik, 2000, game 3
- Kramnik v Leko, Brissago 2004, game 14
- Anand's Immortal
- Anand v Carlsen, Chennai 2013, game 9
- Wei Yi v Bruzón, Danzhou 2015
- Carlsen v Karjakin, 2016, tiebreak game 4
- Carlsen vs Nepomniachtchi, Game 6 (2021)
- Bogoljubov v Alekhine, Hastings 1922
- Alekhine v Nimzowitsch, San Remo 1930
- Spassky v Fischer, 1972, game 1
- Ivanchuk v Yusupov, Brussels 1991
- Short v Timman, Tilburg 1991
- Kasparov v Anand, 1995, game 10
- Deep Blue v Kasparov, 1996, game 1
- Deep Blue v Kasparov, 1997, game 6
- Polgar v Kasparov, Moscow 2002
- Carlsen v Ernst, Wijk aan Zee 2004
- Topalov v Anand, 2010, game 12
- Carlsen v Anand, 2014, game 6
- AlphaZero v Stockfish, 2017
- Bai Jinshi v Ding Liren, 2017
- Ding v Gukesh, 2024, game 14