ptiChess

Deep Blue v Kasparov, 1997, game 6: the machine wins

On 11 May 1997 in New York, Garry Kasparov sat down for the sixth and last game of his rematch with IBM's Deep Blue with the score level at 2½–2½. He had won the first game, lost the second, and drawn the next three. Little more than an hour later he resigned after 19 moves, and a computer had beaten the world champion in a match for the first time.

a8b7c6d5e4f3g2h1
White to move after 7...h6. Deep Blue's next move gives up a knight on e6.

Find the move. Find the move Deep Blue played at move 18.

Find the move

The whole game

a8b7c6d5e4f3g2h1
Deep Blue v Kasparov, New York 1997, game 6. Step through all 19 moves; Black resigned.

Kasparov chose the Caro-Kann, a defence he rarely played, and on move 7 he played ...h6, a move earlier than usual. Deep Blue answered by giving up a knight on e6, and Black's king never found safety.

What Stockfish makes of it

We had Stockfish check every move. It agrees that the knight sacrifice works, and it finds that Kasparov's real trouble came a move later.

7...h6: a move too early

a8b7c6d5e4f3g2h1
7...h6 8.Nxe6 Qe7 9.O-O fxe6 10.Bg6+ Kd8: the knight is gone, and Black's king is stuck in the centre.

The usual order is 7...Bd6 first, and Stockfish agrees: it rates White about half a pawn better after 7...Bd6, and about a pawn better after 7...h6. Wikipedia's account notes that some have called 7...h6 a deliberate anti-computer choice, and that the move is playable but very hard for a human to defend. It is not a losing move on its own.

8.Nxe6 is Stockfish's first choice too. In 1997 it was widely assumed that Deep Blue found it in its opening book rather than by calculation, because the compensation for the knight was hard for computers of that time to see; today's engines play it without a book.

8...Qe7: the real mistake

a8b7c6d5e4f3g2h1
8...fxe6 9.Bg6+ Ke7 10.Bf4 Nd5 11.Bg3 h5: taking the knight at once, Stockfish's choice.

Annotators criticised 8...Qe7, and Stockfish agrees. Taking the knight at once with 8...fxe6 would have kept White's advantage to about a pawn. After 8...Qe7 White is nearly two pawns better.

White still had to be accurate. 9.O-O was the only good move: 9.d5, for instance, would have left Black better. And after 10.Bg6+, 10...Kd8 was forced; 10...Qf7 would have lost at once.

17.Bf5 and 18.Rxe7: the end

a8b7c6d5e4f3g2h1
16...Bc6 17.Bf5 exf5 18.Rxe7 Bxe7 19.c4: Black resigned.

By move 16 Stockfish rated White more than three pawns better. 17.Bf5 gave up the bishop to open the e-file, and 18.Rxe7 won Black's queen for a rook; Stockfish calls 18.Rxe7 the only move that kept White's advantage. 18...Nxe7 was a little better than 18...Bxe7, but after 19.c4 Black's pieces are falling apart and Stockfish rates White nearly five pawns better. Kasparov resigned.

After the game Kasparov said he suspected human help for the machine, which IBM denied. He asked for a rematch; IBM declined and retired Deep Blue.

How we checked

Try it. Real positions, set at your level, every answer checked against the board. No account needed to start.

Start training

More famous games

Ways to train